click here to visit the MyMS website Click here to visit the North Mississippi CW website click here to return to the home page
spacer-clear
    20 Nov 2009 05:48PM NORTH MISSISSIPPI & NORTHWEST ALABAMA ALSO VISIT:   wcbi411.wcbi.com  |  myms.wcbi.com  |  nmscw.wcbi.com   
 
   
     
 
09 Nov 2009 01:38pm | Posted by Steve Rogers | Local News, Political, Business, Faith & Family, Health
Study Links Decline in Heart Attacks to Smoking Bans

STARKVILLE, Miss.-- A Mississippi State study released Monday [Nov. 9] shows a 27 percent decrease in heart attacks among Starkville residents since the city passed a smoking ban in 2006.

Researchers associated with the university report also are recommending a statewide public ban on smoking.

The study by Robert McMillen and Dr. Robert Collins shows fewer heart attacks being treated at the Oktibbeha County Hospital. It focused on Starkville residents in the three-year span after the ban became law, compared to three years prior.

McMillen is an assistant professor in the psychology department and researcher at MSU's nationally recognized Social Science Research Center; Collins is director of University Health Services.

Their findings are part of a larger SSRC evaluation of Mississippi communities that passed smoking bans in recent years. McMillen said the data shows Starkville benefitting medically from the smoking ban.

"The emerging scientific consensus clearly demonstrates that communities like Starkville can reduce heart attacks simply by prohibiting smoking in indoor public places," McMillen said. "Smoke-free laws are popular with the public and are free to implement."

The MSU investigation mirrors findings of a federally commissioned panel of scientists recently made public. Commissioned by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, that report by the independent and non-profit Institute of Medicine examined information from 11 studies of communities in Canada, Italy, Scotland, and the United States.

The CDC/IM conclusion: Bans on smoking in public places reduces cases of heart attacks and heart disease.

"Our research substantiates that report from the Institute of Medicine," McMillen said.

In addition to Starkville, larger Mississippi communities with public-place smoking bans include Tupelo, Meridian, Hattiesburg, Greenwood, Grenada, and Pontotoc. In all, some two dozen Magnolia State municipalities have bans.

Nationwide, 17 states, Puerto Rico and the District of Columbia ban smoking in bars, restaurants and workplaces. Also, 14 other states and more than 350 cities and towns ban smoking in one or two of those types of establishments, according to the advocacy group Americans for Nonsmokers' Rights.

Collins, an MSU physician since 1977, said the 27 percent decrease in heart attacks in Starkville translates into 14 fewer heart attacks for local citizens and an estimated $750,000 not spent on heart attack aftercare, based on reports of the average financial costs for heart attacks.

Data from the Mississippi State Department of Health and national figures indicates the state would save an estimated $125 million annually in health care expenses if a legislatively mandated smoking ban was enacted, he added.

"I plead with the Mississippi Legislature to ban smoking in public places," Collins said. "Our data reflects the findings of every other community that has looked at what happened when smoking is banned in public venues."

Roy Hart, director of the Office of Tobacco Control at the Mississippi State Department of Health, also supports additional smoking bans in public places. He said enacting smoking restrictions is one of the simplest, healthy and cost effective "tobacco control strategies."

"Smoking restrictions save lives, reduce health care costs and youth smoking initiation, and encourage smokers to quit," Hart said.

Anti-smoking advocacy groups in Mississippi, including chapters of the American Heart and American Stroke associations, long have supported efforts to ban smoking in public places throughout the state.

"Improving the health of Mississippians is the main reason that groups all across the state fight for comprehensive smoke-free laws," said Katherine Bryant, public advocacy director for both Jackson-based organizations.

"The American Heart Association, along with other coalition partners, hopes our lawmakers realize how vital strong smoke-free laws are to the health of all Mississippians," Bryant added.



Comments & Article Feedback:


12 Nov 2009 07:54 am | Posted by Kevin
In keeping with the current spirit in promotion of medically prescribed self interest. The solution is clear;

If you break someone's nose in reaction to their complaints regarding cigarette smoke. They can no longer detect the smell, and in a win-win kind of way, they no longer fear the smoke, problem solved.

Thanks Public Health...

If there is an effect, considering the massive number of those affected, it would obviously have to represent a negative health consequence.

Smoking bans currently afford less protection, than we legislate as criminal acts when describing what is necessary in the care of a dog.

How do you quantify the effect of both natural elements of weather and biological risks and potential forced victimization by exposure to criminal elements when we insist women stand away from all enclosed spaces and lighted areas?

11 Nov 2009 04:02 am | Posted by Dave Atherton
The diet of unyielding anti smoking proganda based on spurious facts knows no bounds. The reduction is probably no more than a coincidence.

The Universities of Wisconsin and Stanford did a study of heart attacks over an 8 year period, examined a total of 217,023 heart attack admissions and 2.0 million heart attack deaths in 468 counties in all 50 states. Its conclusions were:

1. "In contrast with smaller regional studies, we find that workplace bans are not associated with statistically significant short-term declines in mortality or hospital admissions for myocardial infarction or other diseases."

2. "An analysis simulating smaller studies using subsamples reveals that large short-term increases in myocardial infarction incidence following a workplace ban are as common as the large decreases reported in the published literature."

This is no more than cheap scare mongering.

http://www.nber.org/papers/w14790.pdf

09 Nov 2009 09:06 pm | Posted by Michael J. McFadden
" 'Improving the health of Mississippians is the main reason that groups all across the state fight for comprehensive smoke-free laws,' said Katherine Bryant, public advocacy director for both Jackson-based organizations."

Really? I thought it had something to do with all the money they get paid from the MSA and the NicoGummyPatchyPeople and such.

Back a few years ago the New Jersey BREATHES program was told that its budget was being cut to JUST fourteen million dollars. Paul Wallner of the Medical Society of New Jersey said €œEverything stops. There is no money.€ (Ralph Siegel. Associated Press 01/08/02)

When $14,000,000.00 is referred to as "no money" there is clearly something very, very wrong... as the people dedicated to "improving the health" just stop working.

Michael J. McFadden,
Author of "Dissecting Antismokers' Brains"

09 Nov 2009 08:31 pm | Posted by ladyraj
laughing The CDC/IM research failed to include data from a myriad of studies that found no association of smoking bans with improved heart outcomes. Further, the studies included in the MI report had cities with small populations evaluated 6 month before and after the smoking ban was enacted. How can one believe that double digit decreases in heart attack incidence could occur in such a brief interval? The Statin drugs have less efficacy than smoking bans according to this report.

Starkville has a 27% decrease in heart attack attributed to the smoking bans and equated with 14 less heart attacks over 3 years. This appears to be the standard error rate rather than any true effect.

14 less heart attacks...did the author of the study control for medical and drug improvements and compliance in this study? Could this be a fluke and next year the average rate will rebound with the added delayed incidence...stay tuned. But, one can bet no one will print those figures.

09 Nov 2009 04:50 pm | Posted by harleyrider1978
Here is the NBER paper.

http://www.nber.org/tmp/53834-w14790.pdf

March 2009

"This paper analyzes nationally representative databases, including the Nationwide Inpatient Sample, to compare short-term changes in mortality and hospitalization rates in smoking-restricted regions with control
regions. In contrast with smaller regional studies, we find that workplace bans are not associated with statistically significant short-term declines in mortality or hospital admissions for myocardial infarction or other diseases. An analysis simulating smaller studies using subsamples reveals that large short-term increases in myocardial infarction incidence following a workplace ban are as common as the large decreases reported in the published literature."

Bans have no short term impact on health. Some bans, in some states, have been on the books for over a decade and they have not had any impact on health either.

Ergo - bans are not about health, health issues regarding tobacco smoke are just lies used to justify bans.

Imagine that! Killed by a smell!

09 Nov 2009 04:07 pm | Posted by Pro Smoking Ban
I wish our city councilman would read this article and pay close attention to it.. and pass the smoking ban in columbus. This town is so backwards in their beliefs and its time we get with the program. Banning smoking is not being socialistic as you smokers like to claim. I am entitled to go to ANY public establishment and not be subjected to smoke. If you want to smoke and kill yourself at home, thats your business but don't inflict it on non-smokers.
Add a Comment:
All comments must be reviewed and approved by WCBI before they will be posted on the website.

Name:
E-mail: (optional)
Smile:
smile wink wassat tongue laughing sad angry crying 
| Forget Me
Content Management Powered by CuteNews
 

Click here to visit the official Reed's website at www.reeds.ms

Johnson Carpet Center: offering more than just carpet!

spacer-clear
click here to visit the official Smack Down website
Popular Searches
Powered by PremierGuide
 
spacer
spacer-clear
spacerHOME  |  NEWS  |  WEATHER  |  SPORTS  |  COMMUNITY  |  VIDEO  |  FEATURES  |  PROGRAMMING  |  CONTESTS  |  BEHIND THE SCENES
spacer
Copyright © 2008 WCBI-TV, LLC & Morris Multimedia, Inc. All Rights Reserved
CONTACT DIRECTORY |   PRIVACY POLICY  |  COMMENT POLICY |   EEO PUBLIC REPORTS  |  FCC 388

spacer